Sunday, May 18, 2014

Nonverbal Girl's Individuality Revealed Through Typing


There's a particular video that was sent to me, asking for my thoughts about it. It's about an 11-year-old nonverbal autistic girl that has learned how to type. You may have seen it, or if not this particular one, some story like it. Here it is if you haven't seen it:


The first thing I notice is also the most obvious. Carly Fleischmann is an intelligent young girl, who simply had no ability to express that intelligence for most of her life. This is a phenomenon that we're seeing a lot these days. Many so-called “low-functioning” autistics have found alternative ways to communicate with others, and in doing so, have revealed an intelligence that is often above the normal range.

This story, and others like it, are almost an embodiment of the phrase “not being able to speak is not the same as having nothing to say.” Every one of these people that comes to public attention has something to say. They all appear to want it to be known that they are complete human beings, with feelings, and want nothing more than to be able to live a happy life. I find it heartening to see that people are listening.

I think this phenomenon also calls into question the validity of describing these individuals as being intellectually disabled. Carly is able to express her thoughts clearly and articulately through typing. But I think I can extend this point even further than that. If you're reading this, it's likely that you know at least one autistic person, if not several. Ask yourself, have you ever met an autistic person that you could definitively say was less intelligent than the average person? Or were some simply unable to express themselves enough to be seen as intelligent people. I can't say that all completely nonverbal individuals are highly intelligent. Only that it makes no sense to assume that they're intellectually disabled.

Another observation was specifically mentioned by Carly's father. He realized when she started typing that when he used to talk about her as if she wasn't there, that she could understand every word. This should always be assumed. It always saddens me to hear people talking about their family members like this, right in front of them. No one likes to be talked about in their presence. Even if the person does not understand what is being said about them, it does no harm to treat them with this kind of human dignity.

This leads to one more point that I would like to say. It's something I see in other stories like this, as well as the differences between “low-functioning” and “high-functioning” individuals, though it's rarely talked about. I saw a distinct difference in how Carly was treated by her parents before and after she started typing. Look back at the video and see if you can see it. She was being held down and restrained while screaming and flapping before.

Before anyone jumps on me for blaming parents, I do understand the desire to protect her from harming herself. However, I'm not sure how much danger there is in that happening to begin with. When I've done things like that in the past, the best thing to do would have been to simply leave me alone and let me calm down on my own. Trying to hold me down and stop me from hurting myself would have only made things worse.

Back to the video, you might have noticed that after Carly began typing, her parents were forced to think of her as a teenage girl. When that happened, they started treating her like a teenage girl, and she started acting like a teenage girl. People do tend to be products of their environment.

I have some personal experience in this area as well. I used to work with someone who, for a solid month or two, treated me like I was low-functioning, and made no secret of the fact that she thought of me as Rainman. What happened was I started closing in on myself. Not just at work, but everywhere. I felt like I was becoming more low-functioning. I learned later that other people that had nothing to do with my job were noticing as well. This is at odds with every other stage in my life, when I've been treated as a functioning human being, and I've been able to live up to that.

The final point I would like to make here is that I feel that a person's level of functioning is much more fluid than is commonly believed. For this reason, I feel we have little need for two terms that I've used here: low-functioning and high-functioning. Just remember that when you see a profoundly autistic person, remember that there is a fully-fleshed out human being in that body, and treat them accordingly.

Thursday, May 8, 2014

The Wallflower and the Butterfly


One of the biggest hurdles for people with ASD ( Autism Spectrum Disorder) is social interactions. For me, its a especially hard as most of my life I have been around “normal” folk who have no trouble talking  to others. I am rather a good speaker and can be articulate but I’m not one who can easily approach others  and strike up a conversation.

I recently went to a day long aikid instructor’s class, where over 40 people were in attendence, most I knew from years of  classes and camps and yet I still felt like an outsider. At lunch I sat in a corner alone at a table. While we waited for the afternoon session to start, I stood alone while everyone else chatted. I don’t normally notice this isolation as I’m used to it but since my diagnosis I have become more aware of  how often it happens.

Mind you this is with people I know. I sat in the front seat on a recent car tripwith someone I’ve known for years, and we barely exchanged words. However, on the way back another person sat up front and the two chatted away. So does she prefer the other person’s company or I am a poor conversationalist? It’s hard for me to tell.

I try to improve my social skills but it’s a struggle. I fret awkwardly, trying to go beyond small talk--which I'm terrible at and wonder how dull or boring I sound. Every social encounter  is scrutinized, analyed and graded as a success or failure. Did I monologue? Did I stay on topic subject or dominate with one of my fixations? How well did I reciprocate ? Did I show interest in them or just wait impatiently until I could babble on.The stress is considerable.

I’m reminded of  what John Elder Robison commented in his memoir “Look Me in the Eye.”
“ Many descriptions of autism and Asperger’s  describe people like me as “not wanting contact with others” or “preferring to play alone.” I can’t speak for other kids, but I’d like to be very clear about my own feelings:  I did not ever want to to be alone . And all those child psychologists who said ”John prefers to play by himself” were dead wrong. I played by myself because I was a failure at playing with with others. I was alone as a result of my own limitations, and being alone was one of the bitterest disappointments of my young life.”

I understand that all too well. Just because  I’m not good at interacting doesn’t mean I don’t want to and the pain of loneliness is as powerful for someone with ASD as it is for anyone. So should you see me --or someone you know  with ASD at a gathering , please come over and talk , I crave conversation too and will appreciate the kindness of your company.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

The Myth of the Autism Epidemic


It's no secret that the rate of autism diagnoses has risen dramatically in recent decades. In the 1980s, it was reported that only one person out of every 2,000 were autistic. The current estimate is one in 68 people are autistic. Looking at those numbers, it's only natural to assume that there is a massive epidemic of a once rare condition.

The problem with this line of reasoning is that it assumes that the rate of autism diagnoses is the same as the rate of autism occurrence. To put it simply, it's like the classic question asking the world's highest peak before Mt. Everest was discovered. Anyone familiar with this question will tell you that Mt. Everest did, in fact, exist before it was discovered. I am submitting that in a similar way, autism did not actually become more prevalent. It's simply more recognized.

It's well known that in recent years, professionals have learned a lot about how to recognize autism. It really should come as no surprise that when you know how to find something, you are likely to find more of it. In addition, there are a lot more autism professionals. Many of them have moved into areas that have not previously had autism professionals. Again, when you have more people looking for something in more places, the prevalence will probably appear higher than it did before.

We might also look at what autism was seen to be in the 1980s compared to now. In the 80s and before, a person would have to be completely nonverbal to be considered autistic. The definition has changed considerably since then. There are now people receiving autism diagnoses that most people would see only as being weird or eccentric. Remember that Asperger's is also considered to be a form of autism, to the point that the American Psychiatric Association has recently redefined it as mild autism. This change in how we define autism has, just by itself, contributed hugely to the perceived increase.

I think I can further demonstrate my last point by saying that there are studies showing a similar autism rate among adults. I can remember reading one a few years ago that looked at a random sample of adults and tested them for autism under current (at the time) diagnostic standards. The result showed a rate just below, but not statistically significant from, the autism rate seen among children at the time. Further, many of you reading this probably personally know one or more undiagnosed aspies. These are people that would have received diagnoses as children, had the definition been the same as it is now.

Another thing of note is that as autism diagnoses increase, some other diagnoses have actually been known to decrease. This indicates that some conditions are being increasingly recognized as autism. I feel that there is likely to be a certain amount of misdiagnosis involved in this phenomenon. Either some conditions have been recognized as separate when they are actually a different form of it (such as Asperger's), or some are now being recognized as autism when I don't feel that they should be (such as childhood degenerative disorder).

One more point is the evidence of autism existing in its current form throughout history. It's almost cliché to refer to such historical figures as Albert Einstein and Thomas Jefferson as likely being autistic. It is true that that is pure speculation. I won't go very deep into the evidence of it here, but what I've seen is certainly compelling. They tended to exhibit speech patterns and thought processes that are common in autistic people. Anthropologists have even pointed out that cave paintings from prehistoric times appear very similar to drawings made by modern day autistic “savants.”

I know some may point out all of the research that has been put into finding a cause of autism. This research has yielded consistently inconclusive or even negative results. I think it's safe to conclude that autism is genetic, and has existed throughout human history.

Sunday, April 27, 2014

A few weeks ago, KindTree - Autism Rocks published a news item forwarded from "Asperger Experts". These young men have started a company marketing a "New" approach to dealing with people on the autism spectrum. It sounded pretty good to me, but I forwarded it to our own local expert David Olson, facilitator of KindTree - Autism Rocks "Self Advocacy" discussion group. He in turn shared it with a more active than this one discussion group. Below are few excerpts from that discussion, and the whole thread is here.

What do you think?

from one fellow:
I did not watch all of the first video nor any others at all, but I think I got the jist. I think this video has a place for some very young, perhaps adolescent autistics. So many are now raised as "DISABLED" that learned helplessness is a major issue. These basic social niceties escape them. This guy may have been such and found the path out. More power to him and anyone he helps! Autonomous Autistics Arise!!

I often find that special educators "LOVE" their kids - as long as the kids stay in the "DISABLED" box. If they mature, make something of themselves, and crawl out of the "DISABLED" box into the "MAINSTREAM" box, it freaks people out. These are the people I work with.

I work on two teams of 4 therapists (and only I swing between the two) to cover all of the medically fragile babies birth to 3-years in the 5th largest county in the US and an additional smaller county. I have to help these two busy teams learn how to work with me and me with them* in addition to getting our job done. 

The things that seem to be working for me are:
1. One of the team members quickly became my ally. She recognized I was autistic (most people just assume I am an irritatingly passionate oddball). Since then two more team members have joined "team Janet". This is an absolute 1st for me**

2. I bring my little-professor, powerful narrow-interest-level-knowledge and expertise to the teams - a valuable commodity. Once I get the gestalt of something, the details I can remember astound them. The autistic brain is a thing of beauty!

3. My allies help me interpret interpersonal interactions and help the others not yet on "Team Janet" understand that I mean well, am actually kind and helpful, don't hang on to negative emotions, and have high value despite my unexpected "packaging". 

4. People just need to give me overt feedback without emotional overoad. 

This may sound like a burden, but it really amounts to a few quiet words in passing here and there. 

Sunday, April 20, 2014

Thoughts on Person-First Phrasing


“Person with autism.” We've all been taught that this is the politically correct terminology. The stated reason? It's important to establish that you're talking about a person before anything else. That sounds nice and accepting, doesn't it?

The big problem with this rule is that I don't remember “people with autism” being consulted about it. It is reasonable to assume that a group of people might have an opinion on how they are to be referred to. I'd like to state some of my opinions on it.

Before I continue, I want to stress that what I'm saying here is my opinion and nothing more. I've talked to several autistic people that mostly agree with me, and I've also talked to some who don't. I don't mean to present this as a representative opinion of the entire autistic community. Only as a way to start a discussion.

I'll go ahead and get the obvious part out of the way first. The label can, and probably should, be left out unless it's relevant. Similarly, you wouldn't refer to a person as neuronormal if it isn't relevant.

Now, the real question is when the label is relevant, do you say “autistic” or “person with autism?” The honest truth is that either one can be acceptable. The most important thing is that you speak with respect to the people you're talking about, and that they are not seen as being anything less than full human beings. If you can do that, I don't really care which one you use.

If you've been reading from the beginning, you most likely would have the impression that I have something against the phrase “person with autism.” Here's why. As I said before, the reason given is to establish that you're talking about a person. I'm not exactly comforted by the thought that some people have to remind themselves that I'm a person when they talk about me. I feel that it's a sign of a deeper problem that a simple change in terminology is unlikely to change.

The other reason I'm not fond of person-first phrasing is that it tends to reinforce the idea that autism is akin to a disease. That there is a normal person trapped inside a shell of autism. This is simply not the case. No matter how functional a person becomes, the autism will always be there.

My preference is “autistic.” When something runs as deep as how your brain is wired, it's hard to separate it from the person. Autism isn't simply a set of behaviors. It affects how we think, how we process information, and even how we sense the world around us. It's a part of who we are, and that will never change.

I do understand that there are people who disagree with me because they don't want to be defined by their autism. I completely respect that, and, in fact, I don't want to be defined by it either. However, I don't feel that the answer to this is to go to person-first phrasing. I think the answer is to simply bring it up when it's relevant and not mention it when it isn't.

In conclusion, I believe the most important thing is to see autistic people as people. That should not require stating it before the label, in much the same way that you don't talk about people with homosexuality or people with blackness. Person-first phrasing does not always promote person-first thinking.

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

I am posting this article, written by David Olson, for the KindTree newsletter "Reaching Out - Reaching In". You can access the complete newsletter here: http://www.kindtree.org/html/newsletter.html  I think it's a great article...

Autism Acceptance Month by David Olson


April has been celebrated as Autism Awareness Month since the 1970’s. This, among other things, has made autism into a household word, and has brought into being much research and supports for those who experience autism. Many people are recognized as autistic who may not have even been considered for a diagnosis prior to this increased awareness. It has even caused autistic people to come together and find our own voice.

However, I believe that awareness only goes so far. It does little to ensure that the research being done is helpful to autistic people that currently need supports. It also does not ensure that the supports and therapies offered are actually helpful, nor that they do not cause harm to those they are intended to help. Awareness does nothing to reduce the stigma that comes along with autism, and it does little to make the voice of the autistic community heard.

In 2011, the Autistic Self-Advocacy Network (ASAN) proposed simply changing one word to address these shortcomings. Change awareness to acceptance.

The core principle of acceptance, of course, is to reduce stigma. We in the neurodiversity movement wish for all autistic people to be able to celebrate themselves as the unique individuals they are. Only through acceptance and comfort with ourselves can we strive to achieve our full potential.

I believe acceptance has much farther reaching potential than just that, though. By listening to the wants and needs of the autistic community, research can be directed toward more useful goals. Supports and treatments can be improved with greater insight into the autistic mind. Communication between autistic adults and parent communities can and does promote a greater understanding of autistic children, as well as creating more effective parenting methods.

Please join me this April in celebrating Autism Acceptance Month. If you are autistic and willing to talk about it, talk to people about autism. If you are interested in autism, talk to an autistic person, and don't be afraid to ask as many questions as come to mind.

Share this wherever you can. Together, we can better understand each other and make a better world for us all.
David Olson at Camp

Monday, January 27, 2014

Greetings,

Welcome to the New Year. It is my hope that 2014 will find more and more folks posting, commenting, and following this KindTree - Autism Rocks Blog.

You r personal experiences, your experiences with KindTree - Autism Rocks, your recommendations for books, devices, services and more are all welcome here.

Got any?

Tim