Sunday, February 15, 2015

Medical Model Vs. Social Model for Autism


You may notice that disability rights activists appear to see disabilities in a different light from the general population. Why is that? Well, there are two ways to look at a disability: the medical model and the social model. Both are equally valid, but have different uses. After I describe the two models, I would like to apply them to the disability I'm most familiar with, autism.

Let's start with the medical model of disability, since it's the one people are most familiar with. The medical model can be summed up as being the way a doctor might look at a disability. The purpose is to describe the deficits and inabilities associated with the disability. It strives to find the differences from abled people, and likely causes for those differences.

In terms of autism, the medical model states that a person may not fully understand social interactions, and appear to be lacking in empathy. The person may appear socially withdrawn, pursuing narrow interests. He/she will often follow strict routines, or perform repetitive, stereotyped movements.

The medical model also looks for causes. Is autism caused by vaccines? Air pollution? Chemicals in our food? Or is it simply genetic, and we're only learning in recent decades what to look for?

Since the medical model is focused on determining the exact nature of a disability, it can be used as a starting point for understanding. Even a disabled person can make use of it to better understand him/herself. Once we know the exact nature of a disability, it's easier to understand how that disability can affect a person's life.

However, there is a problem with the medical model. With its focus on a scientific and medical point of view, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that we're looking at human beings, and not simply a set of traits.

This is where the social model comes in. The social model of disability takes a much more humanistic approach. The focus is on the ability, rather than the inability. The goal of the social model is to reduce limitations, while still honoring the diversity of human abilities.

My favorite explanation involves a person who is unable to ascend a set of stairs. According to the medical model, this might be because of severe nerve damage that has limited the person's proprioception to the point where it has effectively no function, compounded by reduced muscle tone in the legs from non-use. The social model would say it's because there is no ramp. Both views are correct, but while one helps to understand the condition, the other helps a person accomplish every day tasks.

Other areas we can see the social model at work are in the existence of sign language, service animals, and Braille. We all recognize the meaning of a white cane. These are all ways in which various disabilities have been integrated into our society, without needing to see them as problems that need to be fixed.

Now the question is how do we apply the social model to autism? Because of the variety of ways in which autism might manifest in each individual, it's difficult to come up with a single, clear cut answer. But there are a few things to keep in mind.

First and foremost, as with all disabilities, we should never lose sight of the fact that we're dealing with actual people. It may not seem intuitive to talk directly to a person, rather than through a caregiver, that seems socially withdrawn, but doing so, at an age appropriate level, is the most likely way to make a person feel included.

Repetitive motions, also called stims, are an important coping mechanism. I could write an entire post just on this subject. Until relatively recently, conventional wisdom was to suppress stimming. However, the result of doing so is usually a meltdown. For now, I'll just say that autistic people should be allowed to stim, so long as there is no danger of self-harm or damage to surrounding objects or people.

Adherence to routine can be viewed as an attempt to reduce unpredictability throughout the day. Many autistic people have a poor working memory, meaning it can be difficult to keep track of what you're doing. An established routine enables a person to overcome this problem by performing daily tasks in a preset manner, and reduces the likelihood of needing to adapt to unexpected circumstances.

These are all things that can help an autistic person function in daily life. But how can we use the traits of autism to allow a person to really excel?

To start, let's reexamine how we look at some of the traits. One of them is intense focus on details. Probably a more concise way to say that is attention to detail. We normally consider that to be a good thing. It's a trait that can lead to talent in art or similar trades. In a workplace environment, an autistic employee would likely be suited to detail-oriented jobs.

But I think we can go even further than that. Remember the narrow interests? I prefer to think of them as focused interests. An autistic person's interests may not be as broad as a neuronormal person's, but they tend to run much deeper. Most autistic people can learn about their interests very quickly. This can be put to use in a variety of ways, depending on the interest and the person. Be creative.

To sum up the answer to the original question, disabled people look at disabilities differently because they tend to use the social model. They don't see themselves as broken. They see themselves as unique and capable human beings with their own strengths and weaknesses.

Sunday, February 1, 2015

Vaccines: An Autistic Perspective


With the outbreak of measles coming out of Disneyland, vaccines have been in the news a lot recently. Thanks to discredited doctor Andrew Wakefield and model Jenny McCarthy, it's practically guaranteed that autism will enter any discussion on vaccines. While an expert in autism may occasionally be consulted, it seems as if the autistic perspective is consistently left out.

I could use this post to state the inability of vaccines to cause autism, or to state that the apparent regional correlation between vaccines and autism may be caused by the fact that those regions tend to have better access to medical care in general. I could talk about the difference between unbonded mercury and mercury in the form of a salt, such as thimerosal. I could bring up the proven effectiveness of vaccines using comparisons to parts of the world where vaccination is not readily available. All of these have been discussed at length, and doing so seems to do little to counter the trend of not vaccinating.

Instead, I would like to talk about how we in the autistic community see the issue. We have some points of view that never get addressed in the public discussion.

To a certain extent, some of us feel slightly responsible for the spread of preventable diseases that result in the deaths of children. I know it isn't our fault. We didn't do anything to cause it. All we did was exist, while others spread the idea that it was because of mercury being injected into us. What most autistic people are seeing is that people are, en masse, rejecting proven preventative medicine based on a hunch.

The primary vaccine in the crosshairs seems to be the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine. Vaccines for the three diseases first became available in the 1960's, and were combined into one in 1971. Most people agree that the apparent explosion in autism started in the 1980's. Several of us in the autistic community dispute that there's an autism epidemic, but that's another subject. The point here is that if the MMR vaccine were to blame, the increase should have been seen in the early 1970's.

I know I said I wasn't going to talk much about the science, but I want to mention one thing. One of the reasons vaccines are blamed for autism is the mercury. This would imply that autism is a form of mercury poisoning. Let's have a look at some typical symptoms of mercury poisoning (source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_poisoning#Signs_and_symptoms):
*Peripheral neuropathy (itching, burning, or pain).
*Skin discoloration.
*Swelling.
*Desquamation (shedding or peeling of skin).
*Profuse sweating.
*Tachycardia (fast heart beat).
*Increased salivation.
*Hypertension (high blood pressure).
Children may show the following symptoms:
*Red cheeks, nose, and lips.
*Loss of hair, teeth, and nails.
*Transient rashes.
*Hypotonia (muscle weakness).
*Increased sensitivity to light.
*Kidney dysfunction.
*Emotional lability.
*Memory impairment.
*Insomnia.
I don't see most of those symptoms in higher occurrence among my autistic friends than I do in the general population. In fact, none of them are listed in the description of autism.

Some say that mercury damages neurons on contact. As far as I know, this is true. However, if this is how vaccines cause autism, it requires autism to be a form of brain damage. That seems like it would make sense to someone who doesn't know how the autistic mind works. The problem is that most of the autistic people I've known in my lifetime have been absolutely brilliant, and have been able to easily accomplish mental tasks outside the abilities of neuronormal people. I can't really say about the others, because of their inability to communicate.

Perhaps the brain damage caused by the mercury only damages the ability to communicate. I see two problems with that explanation. First is that it provides no explanation for the increase in mental abilities in other areas. Second is that brain damage isn't that predictable. The mercury would damage whichever neurons it came into contact with. Those may be in the part of the brain that control communication, or it may happen somewhere completely different. It would depend entirely on where the mercury arrives first.

There's one final point I want to say about mercury. Unlike mercury poisoning, no one has ever died from autism.

That leads me to the biggest point I want to make in this post. Let's go ahead and assume for a moment that vaccines can cause autism. In recent years, children have been dying from preventable diseases, such as measles and whooping cough. Many of us in the autistic community take offense that it would be preferable to risk their children's lives than for them to end up like us.

I understand that an autism diagnosis can be initially devastating for parents, especially combined with some of the things parents are still told about the diagnosis. However, it is becoming more widely acknowledged that an autistic person can live a happy, fulfilling, and productive life.

Refusal to vaccinate is a public health crisis. Diseases that have been almost stamped out are making a comeback. Please don't use our existence as a reason to risk the health and lives of your children and those around them.

Sunday, January 18, 2015

Telling My Life Story


I'm often asked by members of the autism community to talk about my life. While I don't mind doing this, it can be somewhat embarrassing for me. I got to thinking about this recently, and I not only thought of explanations for it, but I realized that it probably isn't that uncommon for people to feel uncomfortable sharing their life stories. I thought it might be fun to explore that here.

The first embarrassment that comes to mind is when people tell me that I inspire them. I often feel that people see my story as one of overcoming adversity, of not letting autism hold me back. I guess some parts of my story are about overcoming adversity, but I've never considered autism to be the adversity I've overcome. I just have different experiences that others aren't used to hearing about.

So maybe people are inspired by the amount of adversity I've faced in my life. After all, I've dealt with bullying and some forms, often subtle, of discrimination. Well, the truth is that there are some forms of adversity that I've never dealt with. I've never felt the pressure to do something stupid just to keep from not being cool. The threat of being a social outcast was almost meaningless to me, since I already spent most of my childhood there. It's true that I grew up in poverty with a single mother, but the fact that my mom did so much to keep that from holding me back makes that her story, not mine. The extent to which autism has been an adversity to me was that I had to go out of my way to learn social norms. Even that is offset by my ability to absorb things like math and science.

Perhaps people are just attracted to stories that are different from what they're used to. When I look back on my life, it seems pretty mundane for the most part. I suspect this is common. We live our own lives, so why should your life seem interesting to you? My audience almost always disagrees with me. They haven't lived my life. Ultimately, it matters more what the listener finds interesting than the teller.

I also notice a tendency to choose to share certain details that are relevant to the audience's interests. When I talk to the autism community, I tend to talk more about how being autistic has affected my life. I think most people tend to do this. I don't think it's a conscious effort, most of the time. However, it is more likely to captivate an audience.

That brings me to my next point. People also tend to take interest in unusual similarities to their own lives. There is a reason I, as an autistic person, am often asked to speak to members of the autism community. People like to know that they aren't alone in the world, that there are others who share the same differences that they experience. Even without the need for support, people like to compare notes and see how others have dealt with similar experiences.

One of the reasons I wanted to write about this was to encourage others to share their life stories. I feel that it's a good way to promote the appreciation of diversity in all of it's forms. It can be an eye opening experience to find out how much you share in common with those who are clearly different, or how different you are from someone you would have considered one of your own. The more we learn about each other, the easier it is to see each other as equals.

Telling your life story is also a fun way to learn about yourself. We all have interesting stories. You don't have to have traveled the world or wrestled a crocodile. All you have to do is be honest about your experiences. It still amazes me when I find people enthralled by things that are just facts of life for me.

Even though people like to hear from me, there's nothing special about me. I just know things people want to learn about, I live in a time when people are willing to hear my perspective, and I'm willing to get in front of people and say it. We all have the first two qualities, whether you know it or not. The third is up to you.

Sunday, January 4, 2015

What's it Like to Be Autistic?


Here's one of the questions that an openly autistic person would do well to get used to answering. If you know any autistic people, you've probably wondered about it, even if you've never thought to ask out loud. What's it like from the inside?

Speaking as an autistic person, this is a very difficult question to answer. The simple answer is I don't know. Autism is the natural state for me, and as such, I have nothing to compare it to. Just like you wouldn't be able to tell me what it's like being neuronormal, having never experienced anything else.

While most people seem to understand that answer, I also realize it might be disappointing. Let me see if I can give you a more detailed answer. Please understand that I can only answer from my own experiences and I can only relate them to my own experiences. Some of what I describe here will seem different or foreign to you, and some may seem familiar. Since much of what I'll talk about are things that most people either don't think to share or are uncomfortable sharing, it's difficult to tell which is which.

Autism is a social disability, so experiences with attempted social interaction seems like a logical place to start. Throughout my school years, I was never really able to get the correct social behavior. The people around me would usually let me know somehow, usually by laughing at me. I never understood during that time exactly what I was getting wrong. All I knew was that, even when I was copying the behavior of others around me, it would still be wrong.

Human behavior is frequently difficult to understand for a naturally logical individual. One thing I've learned is that the neuronormal mind must be trained in logic in order to use it, meaning that there is very little logic involved in normal interactions with others. The autistic mind, on the other hand, is highly logical. This means that when we apply our own way of thinking to the behavior of others, most of it won't make sense. That isn't to say that we can't learn it.

Temple Grandin has described autistic people as being anthropologists from Mars. This is a description that has always made sense to me. I am, almost on an academic level, studying my own culture from the outside. In college, I took classes in psychology, anthropology, and even acting, all of which have helped me to better understand the world around me. Of course, having more experience, seeing more interactions between people, and being around less judgmental people have helped as well.

Despite some of the social difficulties I've had, I can think of three types of communities (outside the autism community) that I've felt very comfortable in. In no particular order, the first is hippies, who tend to be very accepting of diversity and non-standard social behavior. Second is nerds. Many of the characteristic autistic traits, such as obsessive interests, focus on details, and memorization of seemingly useless information, are considered normal in nerd culture. Finally, the martial arts community. Martial artists are taught that the skills they learn are dangerous, and therefore, to try to avoid conflict and get along with those around them. If done well, this can lead to some very open-minded people.

Perhaps the biggest reason for social difficulties in autism is a simple matter of where the focus of attention is directed. My understanding is that most people focus pretty intently on facial expressions, body positioning, and tone of voice, starting as infants. There is a strong emphasis placed on the importance of social conformity.

In contrast, for an autistic person, being excluded from the group, while unpleasant, is not completely devastating. However, there is a trade off. Most of us tend to direct our focus to how things work. Whether it's structural, mechanical, biological, ecological, or even linguistic, we tend to excel at looking at the individual pieces of something and figuring out how they work together. I would guess that this is why many of us learn about things that interest us very quickly. Now that I think of it, I've even had to learn about social rules through this lens.

One question you've probably had on your mind since you started reading this is what is the most frustrating part of being autistic? I would have to say that it's people who think they know something they don't. Throughout my life, people have frequently tried to explain how I experience the world, usually without asking me about it first. Of course, they're also frequently wrong.

This might seem harmless. So people think something that isn't true. So what? In fact, it isn't a problem until people start acting on it. Most of the time, it has been in the form of accommodations I didn't need. I remember one teacher that set up a private room for me for when I was overstimulated. It was my choice when to go there. That's an example of something that worked, and was based on ways I actually experienced things. On the other hand, people have also said before that touching me caused physical pain. It didn't. I just didn't care for it. All that belief did was cause people to be overly careful around me and create an unnecessary distinction between me and everyone else.

A related frustration is when I read studies that are based on false assumptions. For example, the use of some chemical has increased, and autism rates are skyrocketing, therefore there must be some connection. Even worse is when the researcher acknowledges that there might not be a connection, but says that we have to relate it to autism anyway to get people to act. I find that to be highly disingenuous, and likely to negatively affect the researcher's credibility later, and it's insulting to us, as it reinforces the view that we're damaged people.

Are there problems or frustrations that come along with autism? Absolutely. Would I want to do away with them? Not really. I've learned a long time ago that the problems I have getting through life come with benefits that I would never want to be rid of. We all have problems as we go through life, and we all have talents and skills that come along with those. Mine are just part of the autistic experience.

Saturday, January 3, 2015

You Will Be Offically Cool After This Class

Starting Tuesday Jan. 13 I will be teaching an introduction to Ki principles for those with ASD. This 6 week class will teach you how to be calm, centered, reduce anxiety and stress. Check out this link for information on what I'm talking about. E-mail me at alisa_m@efn.org for registeration. Come join the fun.

Sunday, December 21, 2014

The Stresses of Parenting Autism


You've probably heard it before. Autism is a complete burden. It wears down patience of caregivers, tears apart families, and robs people of their lives. There are plenty of blogs around the internet to this effect. If you've been reading about autism, you've probably come across a few of them.

I have two initial reactions to these. First is that autism should not be seen as the enemy. It is not a separate entity, robbing you of your life and your child of his/her humanity. One of the things I devote my life to is the idea that autism is an integral part of an autistic person's identity. Accepting a person means accepting that person's autism as well.

My other response is to say that parenting in general is a stressful job. It's hard to find a parent that isn't tired, especially these days, when it's almost impossible to support a household on a single full time job. Why should families with autistic children be seen any differently?

Well, I have to acknowledge that I'm wrong on this second point. Parenting is certainly stressful. However, developmental disabilities, including autism, present a set of challenges that most parents have no way to prepare for. Most parents of autistic children can't even benefit as much from the experience of their own parents.

The best answer I can think of is to create a network of support programs that are easy to access, well funded, well administered, and that are administered in part by people with the developmental disabilities they are meant to help. After all, we have daycare centers and classes for new parents. For low-income families, we have programs like WIC. It's obvious that we as a society place value on raising children. Why should families with developmentally disabled offspring be on their own?

Parent support groups do exist, and can be very valuable. Many of them also provide childcare for the duration of the meeting. It can be refreshing to know that there are others with the same challenges that you have. One further point about support groups is that I find the best kind of support is the kind that makes you feel good about yourself, despite the problems or challenges you might have. Feel free to try to change the tone of your support group if you do not feel this is the kind of support you're getting.

Unfortunately, support groups for parents of adults seem to be in short supply. There are adults who need full time care and/or supervision. That can be draining, and their parents could really benefit from supporting each other.

One thing that a lot of stressed out parents say is that they don't know what to do. That something like autism doesn't come with a manual. I find myself wondering if classes might help. Again, classes for new parents exist. Why can't we have classes for parents of developmentally disabled children? Of course, each child is different, and some things can only be learned as you go. At the same time, we assign labels because there are certain traits that are common to those who share a common label. It may make the learning process smoother if there is some help in guiding it.

The biggest unfulfilled need that I can see is for respite. In case you don't know, respite is a few hours' relief for the primary care provider. This can take several forms, depending on the needs of the individual. For some, it could be a traditional babysitter or childcare center. A respite provider with knowledge of a person's routines and specific behavioral quirks may be necessary in some cases. As you can imagine, this isn't so hard to find.

The shortage is primarily for people that need full, 24 hour supervision, especially adults. This requires certain kinds of training for things like preventing dangerous or self-harming behaviors. It involves dealing with violent or aggressive actions, while calming the person down. Other kinds of care are required that most people have no experience with. The real problem with providing this kind of respite is that there is a shortage of people that are willing to do it. I was recently talking with some friends of mine about how this problem could be solved. Unfortunately, we were not able to come up with any good answers. If you want to leave any thoughts in the comments section, that would be welcome.

To recap, many of the necessary programs do exist. However, many of them are also underfunded and understaffed. Some programs are offered for free, but others can be prohibitively expensive. These are problems that often prevent families from getting support, or programs being able to adequately provide it.

Many programs are also administered by people who know very little about the developmental disabilities they intend to serve. This is why I feel that developmentally disabled people should play a role in the administration of these programs. We are making progress on that front, however. At least with autism, it's becoming more widely accepted that autistic people are knowledgeable enough to serve autistic people.

There is even movement on this front in government. Ari Ne'eman, a well-known autistic self-advocate, was appointed in 2010 to the National Council on Disability. There is a movement now by the Autistic Self-Advocacy Network (ASAN) to require all autism-related committees to be at least half staffed with autistic people.

In summary, while I may not have started out agreeing about the seriousness of problems raising autistic children, there are some very real problems that need to be solved. Instead of blaming autism, let's work together to push for positive change.

Sunday, December 14, 2014

The Art of Mindfulness


Believe it or not even the scatterbrain of  someone with ASD can do this. Trust me.

I just watched an story about Mindfulness on 60 Minutes. The reporter Anderson Cooper affected a kind of 'gee whiz, can this really work' attitude that reminded me that to Americans, the idea of quietly being in the moment is far out. There is nothing new age or nebulas about this concept. It is an ancient practice simply forgotten in the clutter of modern life and technology.

The story pushed the idea that mindfulness can transform our society and it can, but only if it is embraced as a way to get in touch with the present and not some health gimmick to increase your productivity.
Mindfulness can reduce stress, hospitals and doctors now regularly prescribe meditation for high blood pressure and heart patients. It can help those with mental illness, anger issues and addictions. It can benefit everyone.  
In the modern world we think we have to fill up every available moment using communication devices to constantly take in more information. For what reason? We end up communicating less with people around us as we busily check e-mail and cruise the internet.
What is mindfulness and how is it practiced? It is done thru meditation, by doing nothing. Doing nothing is an active practice where one focuses on being in the present moment, not zoning out and wasting time.
I challenge you to stop rolling your eyes to give mindfulness a try.It costs nothing and takes little time.
Put away your phone, etc. and go to a quiet place where you won't be disturbed. Start by sitting up comfortably with your back straight but not tensed. Sit cross legged, seiza (sitting on your legs Japanese style) or in a straight back chair with your feet flat on the floor. Place your hands in your lap and close your eyes. Focus on your breathing or feeling your body at rest. Relax and breath in through your nose and out of your mouth. When thoughts start to distract you (and they will) just gently let them go by like a passing cloud and refocus on your breathe. Don't worry if you get distracted, it will lessen as you continue. Don't be judgmental about your success or failure, just keep at it. 

 practice this before you go to sleep or when you wake up  and you will see a change.